“Life” of a Soldier, “Human Rights” of a Terrorist and a Court of “Law”

By: A N Roy Col.

I firmly believe terrorists are born to be killed and they do not deserve any rights, forget human rights. Serving defence forces personnel at disturbed area should be beyond questioning by supreme court and law to that effect should be enacted in parliament.

An Army veteran, who lost a family member to a militant’s bullet, has raised agonising posers to the Supreme Court:

How much do you know about the brutality of war?

How many of you have sent your progeny to the armed forces?

Have you ever lost a family member in the defence of the country?

Have you ever experienced – or even know – the pain of losing a young son or having a widowed daughter or seeing your grandchildren grow up without their father?

If not, please do not impede our war effort.

Human rights sound very nice when you and your families are safely ensconced in secure air-conditioned homes, but not when you are facing bullets and stone of a unruly religious fanatic mob.

Applying the Court directions to the Pulwama incident, an FIR will be lodged against Gunner Rishi Kumar who risked his life and killed two terrorists despite being hit on his headgear.

Police investigations will carry on for years haunting him even when posted to other places in India. Courts will issue summons and demand his presence. He will be accused of depriving the ‘innocent’ jihadis of their human rights and asked to justify the killings.

He will be queried: “Are you sure they were terrorists? They did not kill you, why did you kill them?”

He will be asked: “Did you give them adequate opportunity to surrender and reform themselves?”

“Did you give them a fair chance to escape?”
“Did you fire warning shots in the air?”

Instead of lauding his bravery, he will be subjected to judicial witch-hunt. What a disgrace for the nation…!

Subjecting active military operations to judicial review is an outlandish idea.

Whereas all nations empower their soldiers to vanquish enemies of the state, India takes pride in shackling them.

While addressing the U.S. Naval Academy in April 2010, Secretary of Defence Robert M Gates of USA had said:

“You have answered the trumpet call. For my part, I consider myself personally responsible for each and every one of you as though you were my own sons and daughters.

“And when I send you in harm’s way, as I will, I will do everything in my power to see that you have what you need to accomplish your mission – and come home safely.”

Apparently, India’s Supreme Court thinks differently.

Human rights of the enemies of the state appear to be far more important than the security of the country. If the human rights of the terrorist are protected, so that he is able to do what he wants to do, then the Indian State (of which security the soldier is mandated to protect) will be destroyed; the court will be destroyed; the law will be destroyed; and, with that everything, including any human right of any person, will be destroyed.

Finally, as a serving officer commented:

“The Supreme Court has given us two options: Get killed and the country will honour your martyrdom or kill the terrorist and face police/judicial investigations for years.”

His apprehensions are genuine and shared by the most of Indians. Wonder which soldier will look forward to serving in such antagonistic environment!

We cannot fight for India on borders but we can fight for our soldiers’ safety and betterment from the safety of our homes.

1 Comment (+add yours?)

  1. Santanu Dey
    Aug 05, 2019 @ 13:31:06

    Wholeheartedly support the move by one of the Defense Veterans.



Join discussion:

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: